Published Date


Post Owner / Author


Post Category



The case of convicted terrorist-turned-US-citizen Vallmoe Shqaire raises questions not solely about how Shqaire slipped previous the improved vetting course of carried out after 9/11, but additionally about why US regulation enforcement didn’t act extra swiftly as soon as his deception was found.

Federal authorities have been conscious since no less than 2010 that Shqaire was arrested on a bombing-related cost in Israel and served time in jail. They’ve had fingerprint proof conclusively linking him to the terrorist act, dedicated underneath the title Mahmad hadr Mahmad Shakir, since early 2016, based on federal courtroom information.

“Someone dropped the ball,” stated Seamus Hughes, deputy director of the Program on Extremism at George Washington College.

Shqaire, 51, carried out the assault in Israel in 1988 “appearing on the course” of a cell of the Palestine Liberation Group, on the time a terrorist group within the eyes of the US authorities, based on information filed in US District Court docket in Los Angeles.

Regardless of his conviction, which ought to have barred him from even coming into the USA, a lot much less changing into an American citizen, Shqaire’s utility was accepted and he took the oath of allegiance on November 6, 2008, within the waning days of the second George W. Bush administration, the information state.

He was charged in September with illegally acquiring his American citizenship by deliberately withholding his legal report and previous associations.

“By concealing his violent, terrorist conduct, defendant circumvented the procedures our immigration system relies upon upon,” prosecutors wrote in a sentencing memorandum.

Shqaire is at the moment free on bond and residing within the Los Angeles space as he awaits his sentencing, scheduled for Friday.

Convicted terrorist admits she lied to become US citizen
Shqaire’s case marks no less than the second time a convicted terrorist has been made a US citizen after 9/11. Chicago-area resident Rasmieh Odeh pleaded responsible in 2017 to illegally acquiring her US citizenship by not disclosing her 1970 conviction in Israel for her function in a pair of bombings, one among which killed two individuals. Odeh, who turned an American in 2004, has since been stripped of her citizenship and expelled from the nation.

A spokesperson with US Citizenship and Immigration Companies, an company charged with combating immigration fraud and detecting nationwide safety threats, declined to reply detailed questions concerning the processing of Shqaire’s utility, citing a coverage in opposition to commenting on issues involving pending litigation.

In a written assertion, the spokeswoman stated, partially, that the company’s present management “has enhanced the screening and vetting of these in search of immigration advantages to make sure they’re eligible and don’t pose a threat to nationwide safety.”

US to require would-be immigrants to turn over social media handles

A former US immigration official who was engaged within the vetting course of in 2008 advised CNN {that a} obligatory background verify that was in place on the time ought to have detected one thing as egregious as a terrorism conviction, whether or not or not an applicant disclosed it.

The official, who spoke on the situation of anonymity as a result of politically charged nature of immigration points, added, nevertheless, that the system is just pretty much as good as the knowledge it attracts from — a few of it derived from overseas governments.

“Who is aware of whether or not this was in there,” he stated.

Shqaire declined to be interviewed for this text. His lawyer, Mark Werksman, stated in a current interview his shopper has labored as a parking valet in Southern California for years and isn’t a risk to anybody.

His lies to US immigration officers, Werksman stated in a sentencing memorandum, have been a misguided try to flee the chaos of the Center East for “the comparative peace and freedom of life in America.”

“Mr. Shqaire wished nothing greater than to be an American and to contribute positively to American society,” the lawyer wrote.

Regardless of his shopper’s conviction, the case is a humiliation for the federal government, stated Werksman, a former federal prosecutor in Los Angeles.

“On paper, my shopper is a really unhealthy man,” he advised CNN. “So, the query is: How did this occur?”

The voluminous file on Shqaire in Los Angeles federal courtroom spans many years and continents. There are references to the Six-Day Struggle between Israel and its neighbors in 1967, the Palestinian rebellion often called the primary intifada that started twenty years later, and claims of harsh interrogation methods and coerced confessions.

Shqaire, a Palestinian-born Jordanian, says his household of 13 ended up in a refugee camp following the conflict amongst Israel, Egypt, Jordan and Syria. As a younger man within the 1980s, he was recruited by the PLO and have become a violent operative in its “Shabeba” cell, based on confessions obtained by Israeli army officers.

Shqaire underwent coaching with rifles and grenades and discovered the best way to construct bombs, the information state. He mentioned the doable assassination of an Israeli intelligence officer and took part within the beatings of fellow Palestinians suspected of collaborating with the Israelis, together with an incident by which a person was stabbed, based on the information.

In December of 1988, the information state, Shqaire and an confederate constructed a pipe bomb. The confederate positioned it alongside the route of an Israeli bus. Shqaire served as a lookout and advised the opposite man when the bus was in vary. The bomb exploded, however nobody was injured. The paperwork supply no rationalization for the shortage of accidents, regardless of the bomb detonating.

Shqaire would say many years later that his confessions have been the results of coercive interrogations and threats by members of the Israel Protection Forces. He claimed he was overwhelmed, subjected to showers that have been both scalding or freezing and housed for “many weeks” in a darkish cell that was so small, “I used to be unable to even stretch my legs or get up.”

He additionally accused Israeli authorities of repeatedly arresting his father as a method of intimidation, mistakenly capturing his brother within the perception that it was him, and of ousting his household from their residence and sealing it shut with cement.

US prosecutors wrote in a courtroom submitting that “such allegations should not supported by the licensed courtroom information Israel supplied.” Nonetheless, prosecutors stated they aren’t counting on Shqaire’s purported confessions to the Israelis as a part of their case in opposition to him.

Shqaire was sentenced to 10 years in jail in Israel in 1991 for, amongst different issues, inserting a bomb “with the intent to trigger loss of life or hurt.” A army appeals courtroom later diminished the sentence to seven years. Shqaire was launched after serving simply 4 years following the 1993 Oslo peace accords and subsequent agreements.

He first got here to the USA on a customer’s visa in 1999, information present.

That very same yr, he acquired married to a US citizen in a so-called inexperienced card marriage. He paid his bride, whom he first met on their wedding ceremony day, $500, the lady would later inform federal investigators.

His try to acquire a inexperienced card by way of the wedding failed when it resulted in divorce in 2002. However Shqaire married a second time later that very same yr. This time the union lasted longer, and he was capable of apply for and obtain standing as a authorized everlasting resident. All through the method, he indicated he’d by no means been arrested and was not a member of any group, based on information.

In 2008, within the closing stage of his pursuit of US citizenship, he was questioned underneath oath by an immigration officer in Los Angeles. He once more omitted his previous conviction and ties to the PLO.

The US immigration officer who dealt with Shqaire’s utility stated she relied on him to “present full and truthful solutions” about his legal previous and associations, based on courtroom information. Had he accomplished so, the information state, she would have requested additional documentation.

As a substitute, she accepted his utility.

Two years later, Shqaire got here onto the radar of US terrorism investigators, based on paperwork and interviews. He was questioned about repeated cash transfers to the Palestinian metropolis of Ramallah and was characterised in courtroom information as a “topic of curiosity” to the Joint Terrorism Activity Power in Los Angeles in 2011.

Shqaire was by no means charged in reference to the cash transfers, however he was convicted of grand theft in 2011 for his involvement in a bank card fraud scheme. He was given a suspended sentence of 5 years in state jail and spent 4 months in county jail, information present. He was additionally positioned on probation for 5 years.

Werksman, Shqaire’s lawyer, stated in a current interview that his shopper had been maxing out bank cards to get a brand new enterprise off the bottom, and that the cash being despatched abroad was merely to help household, not for something nefarious.

Whereas being questioned in 2010, Shqaire acknowledged having been “arrested and incarcerated in Israel on two completely different events,” based on paperwork recounting the interview. However prosecutors say he falsely advised investigators on the time that he was arrested for collaborating in demonstrations, not terrorism.

“He said that he was younger and silly on the time however was influenced by seeing harmless Palestinian males, ladies, and kids injured or killed by Israelis,” based on courtroom paperwork. “Shqaire claimed he would have by no means participated in occasions if he knew the results.” He stated he didn’t recall whether or not he’d disclosed his arrests to US immigration officers, the paperwork state.

For years, federal authorities continued working behind the scenes to unearth Shqaire’s previous.

By 2013, they’d obtained licensed Israeli courtroom paperwork associated to his conviction and submitted to them to Hebrew language specialists for translation to English. The translated paperwork have been then supplied to Division of Homeland Safety brokers and federal prosecutors “on a rolling foundation” over time.

In February 2016 a forensic skilled with the Division of Homeland Safety was capable of match Shqaire’s prints from his 2010 arrest in California with these from his 1990 arrest in Israel underneath the title Mahmad Hadr Mahmad Shakir.

Lastly, in October of final yr, brokers armed with a search warrant raided Shqaires’ condo south of Los Angeles, and he was arrested and charged with illegal procurement of US citizenship.

In January he entered right into a plea settlement subjecting him to the potential for jail time, and agreeing to the lack of his citizenship and removing from the nation.

Werksman is in search of a sentence of probation, arguing that Shqaire relinquishing his cherished US citizenship and being expelled from the nation “will function a reminder of his mistake for the remainder of his life.”

The lawyer submitted letters from a number of of Shqaire’s associates who described him as a kind-hearted, beneficiant function mannequin and mentor. He was a man, as one former boss put it, “who simply desires to stay his life, journey his bike, go to the seashore, not hassle anyone.”

A youthful co-worker recalled Shqaire, whom he referred to by the nickname “Moe,” as somebody who routinely purchased meals for the homeless and whose good deeds have “a domino impact the place he influences others in a optimistic manner.”

“The Moe you see at this time,” Joseph Sandoval wrote to the decide, “shouldn’t be judged the identical because the Moe from a few years in the past.”

Although Shqaire’s offense is a comparatively minor one in the case of federal sentencing tips, prosecutors requested the decide to place him behind bars for 16 months for what they known as his “assault on our immigration system.”

CNN’s Oren Liebermann and Michael Schwartz contributed reporting.

Please complete the required fields.
Flagged Contents are reviewed by Our Moderators 24 hours a day, seven days a week to determine whether they violate Community Guidelines. Accounts are penalized for Community Guidelines violations, and serious or repeated violations can lead to account termination.

How was the Post?


Log In

Forgot password?

Don't have an account? Register

Forgot password?

Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Your password reset link appears to be invalid or expired.

Log in

Privacy Policy

Login to your account